I'm looking for a fear street story (i think its fear street)?

i'm looking for a fear street story that involves a boy his brother and his brothers girlfriend getting into a car acident. i think several years later he finds this girl and i think during there date or after a few dates she ties him into a chair and starts blaming him for his brothers death.. think she took a sledge hammer to his foot... its all i really remember this was a book i red like 9-11 years ago so i'm surprised i remember this much